Category
stringclasses
4 values
Method
stringclasses
10 values
BSC_Support
float64
2.83
4
BSC_Attribution
float64
2.6
4.03
BSC_Multi_Reference_Synthesis
float64
1.93
4
BSC_Balance
float64
2.03
4.07
BSC_Avg
float64
2.75
3.85
TSQ_Coverage
float64
3
4.23
TSQ_Boundary_Control
float64
3
4.3
TSQ_Organization
float64
3
4.4
TSQ_Insight
float64
2.97
4.5
TSQ_Avg
float64
2.99
4.29
HDQ_Alignment
float64
3.43
4.47
HDQ_Progression
float64
2.43
4.13
HDQ_Specificity
float64
3.07
4.53
HDQ_Local_Synthesis
float64
2.07
4.17
HDQ_Avg
float64
2.75
4.28
MAR_References
float64
3
5
MAR_Visuals
float64
1.29
5
MAR_Layout
float64
4.83
5
MAR_Completeness
float64
3
5
MAR_Avg
float64
3.07
5
Total_Avg
float64
3.18
4.34
Reference
Human
3.87
3.9
3.53
4.07
3.84
4.23
4.23
4.4
4.3
4.29
4.47
4.07
4.37
4.07
4.24
5
5
5
5
5
4.34
General
Codex
3
3.43
2.73
2.03
2.8
3
3
3
2.97
2.99
3.43
2.43
3.07
2.07
2.75
5
1.77
5
5
4.19
3.18
General
GPT Deep Research
3.57
3.77
3.33
2.6
3.32
3.47
3.5
3.53
3.43
3.48
4.1
3.47
4
3.47
3.76
5
1.57
5
5
4.14
3.68
General
Gemini Deep Research
2.83
2.6
2.87
3.5
2.95
3.8
3.83
3.83
3.8
3.82
4.17
3.97
4.17
3.97
4.07
4.6
4.87
4.9
5
4.84
3.92
General
Naive RAG
4
4
3.33
3.6
3.73
3.97
4.3
4.2
3.77
4.06
4.47
3.93
4.53
3.93
4.22
5
1.37
5
5
4.09
4.03
Auto Survey Generation
AutoSurvey
4
4
3.29
3.95
3.81
4
3.86
3.1
4
3.74
4.1
3.14
4.24
3.29
3.69
5
1.29
5
3.38
3.67
3.73
Auto Survey Generation
SurveyForge
4
3.9
3.81
3.19
3.73
4
4
3.24
4
3.81
4.1
3.29
4.19
3.38
3.74
5
1.29
5
4.05
3.83
3.78
Auto Survey Generation
LiRA
3.97
3.97
3.57
3
3.63
4
3.33
3.53
4
3.72
3.97
3.9
4.43
3.93
4.06
3
1.4
4.87
3
3.07
3.62
Auto Survey Generation
InteractiveSurvey
3.1
3
1.93
2.97
2.75
4
3.7
3.83
4
3.88
3.8
3.93
4
4
3.93
4.13
4.77
4.83
5
4.68
3.81
Proposed
DAS
4
4.03
4
3.37
3.85
4
4
4.37
4.5
4.22
4.27
4.13
4.53
4.17
4.28
5
5
5
5
5
4.34